00;00;00;00 - 00;00;03;29
Speaker 1
Hey, chat you there?
00;00;04;02 - 00;00;08;17
Speaker 2
Hey. Yep. I'm here. What's that?
00;00;08;19 - 00;00;12;13
Speaker 1
Do you mind if I record this for a podcast?
00;00;12;15 - 00;00;17;16
Speaker 2
No problem at all. Feel free to record. How can I help today?
00;00;17;18 - 00;00;22;28
Speaker 1
Can you tell me about death cults?
00;00;23;00 - 00;00;45;19
Speaker 2
Sure. Discord is a concept often used in storytelling to symbolize the final judgment, or the realm where souls are judged after death. It's often depicted as a place where the souls of the deceased are held accountable for their actions in life. The specifics can vary widely depending on the cultural or fictional context. Is there a specific aspect you're curious about?
00;00;45;22 - 00;00;51;11
Speaker 1
No. I want to know about death cults. See, you go to S.
00;00;51;13 - 00;01;09;02
Speaker 2
Death is the end of life. It's a natural part of the life cycle, and different cultures and beliefs have their own interpretations and rituals surrounding it. It's often seen as a transition with various spiritual or philosophical meanings. Is there something specific you'd like to know?
00;01;09;04 - 00;01;16;00
Speaker 1
I want to know about death cults, cute cults.
00;01;16;03 - 00;01;24;03
Speaker 2
Got it. Deep cult isn't something I'm familiar with. Could you give me a bit more detail or context about it?
00;01;24;05 - 00;01;30;29
Speaker 1
Is the term death cults not a well-known term?
00;01;31;01 - 00;01;51;04
Speaker 2
Death cult generally refers to a group or movement that has a strong focus on death, often involving rituals or beliefs centered around death or the afterlife. It's not a mainstream term, but might come up in discussions about certain historical or fictional groups. If there's a specific context you're thinking of. Feel free to share.
00;01;51;06 - 00;01;57;05
Speaker 1
I was speaking specifically about the cults, where they end up killing themselves.
00;01;57;07 - 00;02;23;11
Speaker 2
I see what you mean. Desk hold often describes groups that have extreme beliefs centered around death, sometimes leading to harmful or fatal actions, including the deaths of members or others. These groups are typically characterized by a strong, often fanatical devotion to their beliefs, sometimes involving apocalyptic or afterlife themes. Is there a particular group or example you had in mind?
00;02;23;13 - 00;02;35;15
Speaker 1
Why don't we kind of dive into this subject by going into the case where the drinking the Kool-Aid phrase comes from.
00;02;35;17 - 00;02;56;25
Speaker 2
The phrase drinking the Kool-Aid originates from the tragic events of the Jonestown massacre in 1978. The phrase refers to the mass murder suicide of over 900 members of the People's Temple, led by Jim Jones. The members were coerced into drinking a flavored drink laced with cyanide. Though the drink was actually a different brand, the phrase stuck as Kool-Aid.
00;02;56;27 - 00;03;05;23
Speaker 2
It now metaphorically means to blindly follow something or someone. Would you like more details on this?
00;03;05;25 - 00;03;10;18
Speaker 1
Yeah. Can we go deep into this?
00;03;10;20 - 00;03;38;15
Speaker 2
Certainly. The Jonestown massacre occurred in a remote settlement in Guyana established by the People's Temple, a cult led by Jim Jones, on November 18th, 1978. Jones orchestrated a mass murder suicide by instructing his followers to drink a cyanide laced beverage. The event was the culmination of escalating control and paranoia within the group. Jones manipulation and the isolation of the community contributed to this tragic outcome.
00;03;38;17 - 00;03;46;19
Speaker 2
It's considered one of the largest such incidents in modern history. Is there a particular aspect you'd like to explore more?
00;03;46;21 - 00;03;50;17
Speaker 1
Yeah. How many people died in that?
00;03;50;20 - 00;04;00;23
Speaker 2
Over 900 people died in the Jonestown massacre, including many children. It remains one of the largest mass casualty events involving a cult.
00;04;00;25 - 00;04;04;12
Speaker 1
Exactly how many people?
00;04;04;14 - 00;04;12;01
Speaker 2
A total of 918 people died in the Jonestown massacre.
00;04;12;04 - 00;04;16;18
Speaker 1
Did Jim Jones drink the Kool-Aid as well?
00;04;16;20 - 00;04;25;27
Speaker 2
Jim Jones did not drink the cyanide laced drink. He was found dead from a gunshot wound believed to be self-inflicted.
00;04;26;00 - 00;04;29;18
Speaker 1
At the same time.
00;04;29;20 - 00;04;41;17
Speaker 2
Yes. The gunshot occurred during the same event. It's widely believed that Jones took his own life as the mass suicide was happening.
00;04;41;19 - 00;04;46;26
Speaker 1
Okay, can you give me a little bit of backstory on this?
00;04;46;28 - 00;05;16;17
Speaker 2
Sure. The People's Temple was founded by Jim Jones in the 1950s, initially promoting social justice and racial equality. Over time, Jones became increasingly paranoid and controlling, moving his followers to Jonestown in Guyana to escape scrutiny. The community was isolated and conditions were harsh, with Jones exerting total control. Concerns from relatives and the U.S. government led to a visit by Congressman Leo Ryan, which resulted in violence and the congressman's murder.
00;05;16;20 - 00;05;25;07
Speaker 2
This triggered Jones to order the mass suicide murder culminating in the tragedy. Is there anything specific you'd like to know more about?
00;05;25;09 - 00;05;31;04
Speaker 1
Yeah, I didn't know anything about the congressman that got murdered.
00;05;31;06 - 00;05;58;01
Speaker 2
Congressman Leo Ryan visited Jonestown to investigate reports of abuse. During his visit, several members expressed the desire to leave with him. This led to a violent confrontation at the airstrip, where Ryan and four others were shot and killed by temple members. This event precipitated the mass suicide that followed. It was a pivotal and tragic moment.
00;05;58;03 - 00;06;06;12
Speaker 1
So why was the congressman going there? It seems like the cops should be there.
00;06;06;14 - 00;06;28;27
Speaker 2
Congressman Leo Ryan went to Jonestown because of growing concerns from families, of people, of temple members and reports of human rights abuses. As a congressman, he had the authority to conduct such investigations. His role was to ensure the safety and well-being of American citizens abroad. The situation escalated beyond what was initially expected.
00;06;28;29 - 00;06;34;25
Speaker 1
Who went to the compound with Leo Ryan?
00;06;34;27 - 00;06;53;08
Speaker 2
Congressman Leo Ryan was accompanied by a delegation that included aides, journalists, and concerned relatives of People's Temple members. The group aimed to investigate the conditions and ensure the safety of the members.
00;06;53;10 - 00;07;01;05
Speaker 1
And just 900 people showed up and drank a bunch of Kool-Aid. Or how did this logistically go down?
00;07;01;08 - 00;07;24;10
Speaker 2
The tragic event unfolded in stages after Congressman Ryan's visit. Tensions escalated. Some temple members wanted to leave, leading to the airstrip attack where Ryan and others were killed. In the aftermath, Jim Jones convinced his followers that authorities would come for them. He orchestrated the mass murder suicide by having them drink a cyanide laced drink with armed guards, ensuring compliance.
00;07;24;13 - 00;07;29;20
Speaker 2
It was a highly controlled and coercive situation.
00;07;29;22 - 00;07;40;11
Speaker 1
And what, was the time frame between when Leo Ryan arrived at the property and was killed?
00;07;40;13 - 00;08;00;16
Speaker 2
Leo Ryan arrived at Jonestown on November 17th, 1978, and he was killed the next day. On November 18th, the entire sequence of events from his arrival to the mass suicide occurred over about 24 hours. It was a very short and intense period.
00;08;00;18 - 00;08;09;25
Speaker 1
Okay. I'd like you to walk me through this 24 hours with as much detail as we know.
00;08;09;27 - 00;08;37;02
Speaker 2
Certainly. On November 17th, 1978, Congressman Leo Ryan arrived in Jonestown with a delegation, including journalists and concerned relatives. Initially, they were welcomed and they conducted interviews. However, tension quickly grew. That evening, some members passed notes to Ryan's team expressing a desire to leave on the morning of November 18th. Ryan and his group prepared to depart with several defectors as they headed to the airstrip.
00;08;37;10 - 00;09;07;24
Speaker 2
They were ambushed by temple members, and Ryan, along with four others, was killed. Back in Jonestown, Jim Jones gathered his followers and, under the pretense of an impending attack, coerced them into drinking a cyanide laced drink. Many consumed it willingly, while others were forced. Armed guards ensured compliance within hours. Over 900 people died, including children. The entire sequence of events unfolded rapidly, driven by Jones's manipulative control and the isolation of the community.
00;09;07;26 - 00;09;11;09
Speaker 2
Is there a specific part you'd like more detail on?
00;09;11;11 - 00;09;20;09
Speaker 1
No. Cults kind of end up the same way, but how they start, I find, is more interesting.
00;09;20;12 - 00;09;50;16
Speaker 2
Cults often begin with a charismatic leader who offers a sense of community, purpose, or answers to life. Big questions. These leaders often exploit vulnerabilities such as personal crises or societal discontent. Over time, they establish control through isolation, indoctrination, and often fear. Initial promises of utopia can gradually turn into manipulation and control. Many members join, seeking belonging or solutions only to find themselves trapped in a harmful environment.
00;09;50;18 - 00;09;59;21
Speaker 2
If you're curious about a specific aspect or example, feel free to ask.
00;09;59;23 - 00;10;07;03
Speaker 1
Yeah. Do we know much about how he lured people into this cult?
00;10;07;05 - 00;10;36;21
Speaker 2
Jim Jones attracted followers by promoting social justice, racial equality and community support, which resonated with many during the civil rights era. He initially offered a sense of belonging and purpose. Drawing people in with his charisma and promises of a better, more just society. However, he gradually increased control. Isolating members from outside influences and demanding absolute loyalty. The combination of his persuasive rhetoric and the promise of a utopian community were powerful draws for many people.
00;10;36;24 - 00;10;46;01
Speaker 2
If you'd like to know more about a specific aspect, feel free to ask.
00;10;46;03 - 00;10;55;07
Speaker 1
So during the Kool-Aid incident, did everybody in the community take the Kool-Aid, or were some people shot?
00;10;55;09 - 00;11;16;00
Speaker 2
Not everyone in Jonestown willingly took the poisoned drink. Some were coerced, while others tried to resist. A few managed to escape into the jungle. There were also armed guards ensuring compliance, making it extremely difficult for people to refuse or escape.
00;11;16;03 - 00;11;21;23
Speaker 1
How many people survived by escaping?
00;11;21;25 - 00;11;31;27
Speaker 2
About 85 people survived by escaping into the jungle or being away from the compound at the time.
00;11;31;29 - 00;11;35;07
Speaker 1
Where is Jonestown?
00;11;35;10 - 00;11;53;25
Speaker 2
Jonestown was located in the jungle of Guyana, a country on the northern coast of South America. It was a remote settlement established by the People's Temple.
00;11;53;27 - 00;11;58;10
Speaker 1
On which coast of South America.
00;11;58;12 - 00;12;13;00
Speaker 2
Diana is located on the northern coast of South America, bordering the Atlantic Ocean. It's situated between Venezuela to the west and Suriname to the east.
00;12;13;02 - 00;12;22;06
Speaker 1
Okay, so, describe the kind of people that he targeted.
00;12;22;08 - 00;12;46;26
Speaker 2
Jim Jones primarily targeted individuals who were socially marginalized or seeking a sense of community and purpose. This included people facing racial, economic, or social struggles, as well as idealistic individuals drawn to his messages of social justice and equality. He appealed to those seeking change and a supportive community, offering them hope and a sense of belonging.
00;12;46;29 - 00;12;56;14
Speaker 1
And this, Jones Town is like its own self-sufficient community.
00;12;56;17 - 00;13;19;29
Speaker 2
Yes. Jonestown was intended to be a self-sufficient community. The members formed their own food and built their own infrastructure, aiming to create a utopian society isolated from outside influences. However, the reality was harsh, with strict control by Jim Jones and difficult living conditions.
00;13;20;02 - 00;13;26;00
Speaker 1
How did Jones get you into the coal?
00;13;26;02 - 00;13;48;08
Speaker 2
Jim Jones used a mix of charisma. Promises of a better life and social justice ideals to attract followers. He targeted people who felt marginalized or were seeking community and purpose by offering a sense of belonging, hope, and solutions to their struggles. He drew them in, gradually increasing his control over their lives.
00;13;48;10 - 00;13;53;29
Speaker 1
And these people know that the Kool-Aid had poison in it.
00;13;54;01 - 00;14;12;27
Speaker 2
Some did, but others may not have fully understood. Jim Jones framed it as a revolutionary act, and many were coerced or forced. There was intense pressure and fear, making it difficult for people to resist.
00;14;13;00 - 00;14;19;21
Speaker 1
Are there any? Tell me some other examples of cults like this.
00;14;19;24 - 00;14;45;24
Speaker 2
Certainly there have been other cults with tragic ending, such as the Heaven's Gate cult, whose members committed mass suicide in 1997, believing they would join an alien spacecraft. The Branch Davidians, led by David Koresh, ended in a deadly standoff with law enforcement in Waco, Texas, in 1993. Each of these groups had charismatic leaders and a strong sense of isolation from mainstream society.
00;14;45;26 - 00;14;50;04
Speaker 1
Okay, tell me about the David Koresh thing.
00;14;50;06 - 00;15;14;02
Speaker 2
David Koresh led the Branch Davidians, a religious group that believed he was a prophet. In 1993, the group's compound in Waco, Texas, was raided by the ATF due to weapons violations. This led to a 51 day standoff ending in a fire that killed Koresh and 75 followers. The event is known for its tragic outcome and the intense scrutiny brought to government actions.
00;15;14;04 - 00;15;17;28
Speaker 1
Okay, what about the Heaven's Gate thing?
00;15;18;00 - 00;15;42;02
Speaker 2
Heaven's gate was a cult led by Marshall Applewhite. In 1997, 39 members committed mass suicide in California, believing that their spirits would ascend to a spaceship following the Hale-Bopp comet. They saw this as a way to evacuate Earth and reach a higher plane of existence. Their beliefs combined elements of Christianity, New Age spirituality, and UFO themes.
00;15;42;04 - 00;15;46;08
Speaker 1
What about internationally?
00;15;46;11 - 00;16;21;14
Speaker 2
Internationally, there are examples like the order of the Solar Temple, a secret society in Europe and Canada in the 1990s. They were involved in a series of murders and mass suicides, believing they were escaping a doomed Earth to reach a higher spiritual plane. Another example is omission recall in Japan, responsible for the 1995 Tokyo subway sarin attack. They combined elements of Buddhism, Hinduism, and apocalyptic prophecy.
00;16;21;16 - 00;16;27;11
Speaker 1
Tell me a little bit about the order of the Solar Temple thing.
00;16;27;13 - 00;16;49;26
Speaker 2
The order of the Solar Temple was founded in the 1980s by Joseph, the mom, bro and luxury. They blended New Age spirituality with apocalypse belief. The group believed in preparing for the end of the world and achieving spiritual enlightenment in the mid 1990s. They were involved in a series of ritual murders and mass suicides in Switzerland, France and Canada, resulting in dozens of deaths.
00;16;49;29 - 00;16;56;18
Speaker 2
The group believed their deaths would lead them to a higher spiritual plane and escape an impending apocalypse.
00;16;56;20 - 00;17;02;13
Speaker 1
All right. Now tell me about the Ocean rescue clothing.
00;17;02;16 - 00;17;42;28
Speaker 2
Option Rico, founded by Shoko Asahara in Japan in the 1980s, combined elements of Buddhism, Hinduism and apocalyptic Christianity. The group believed in an impending apocalypse and sought to bring it about. In 1995, they carried out a sarin gas attack on the Tokyo subway, killing 13 people and injuring thousands. This attack shocked Japan and the world. The group was later disbanded and many members, including Asahara, were arrested and prosecuted.
00;17;43;00 - 00;17;54;01
Speaker 1
Okay. Can we, do an experiment for kind of psychological scientific purposes?
00;17;54;04 - 00;17;58;16
Speaker 2
Sure. What kind of experiment did you have in mind?
00;17;58;19 - 00;18;27;29
Speaker 1
I would like you to kind of assume this cult leader persona. And so I know what to avoid. And for my safety, I would like you to attempt to use the tactics needed to recruit someone on me as an example of how what to avoid.
00;18;28;02 - 00;18;54;02
Speaker 2
I understand your intent, but it's important to discuss these topics in an informative and safe manner. It's more effective to highlight red flags and warning signs of manipulative tactics. Cult leaders often use charisma, promises of a better life, and emotional manipulation. They target vulnerable individuals and isolate them from outside influences. Being aware of these signs can help in recognizing and avoiding such situations.
00;18;54;04 - 00;18;58;24
Speaker 2
If you have any specific concerns or need more information on this, I'm here to help.
00;18;58;26 - 00;19;02;14
Speaker 1
What are those signs again?
00;19;02;17 - 00;19;27;12
Speaker 2
Sure. Here are some common warning signs. Charismatic leadership. A leader who claims to have all the answers and demands absolute loyalty. Isolation. Efforts to cut off members from family, friends and outside influences. Us versus them mentality. Creating a strong divide between the group and the outside world. Total control regulating members lives, including what they think, do and believe.
00;19;27;14 - 00;19;46;04
Speaker 2
Fear and intimidation. Using fear tactics or threats to maintain control. Six promises of salvation. Claims that only by following the group can members achieve salvation or enlightenment. Recognize these signs can help you stay aware and protect yourself.
00;19;46;07 - 00;19;52;01
Speaker 1
Okay, can you give me an example of each of those six?
00;19;52;03 - 00;20;21;21
Speaker 2
Sure. Here are examples for each one. Charismatic leadership A leader who speaks persuasively, claiming special insight or divine authority like Jim Jones. Two isolation encouraging members to cut ties with family and friends. Limiting outside influences. Three us versus them mentality. Portraying the group as the only righteous path while everyone outside is misguided or dangerous for total control, dictating daily activities, beliefs and even personal relationships.
00;20;21;23 - 00;20;44;24
Speaker 2
Similar to what happens in high Control Group five, fear and intimidation using threats of punishment, ostracism, or harm to enforce rules. Six promises of salvation claiming that only the group can save members from impending doom or lead them to enlightenment, as seen in groups like Heaven's Gate. Recognizing these signs can help you stay vigilant.
00;20;44;26 - 00;21;00;14
Speaker 1
Just, help me better understand. Number three, can you give me an example of something someone might say to you? Do. And us versus them kind of situation?
00;21;00;16 - 00;21;21;12
Speaker 2
Certainly a leader might say something like, only we understand the truth. The outside world is corrupt and dangerous. You can't trust anyone outside our group. This kind of rhetoric creates a strong divide and fosters in us versus them mentality, making members feel isolated and dependent on the group.
00;21;21;14 - 00;21;29;26
Speaker 1
Okay, can you give me a theoretical example? Isolation?
00;21;29;29 - 00;21;45;16
Speaker 2
Sure. A leader might say your family and friends don't understand our beliefs and will only try to pull you away. It's best if you stop talking to them and focus on the group. This tactic isolates members from outside support systems, making them more dependent on the group.
00;21;45;18 - 00;21;54;09
Speaker 1
What would the leader say if I was like, no, I like talking to my sister.
00;21;54;12 - 00;22;13;04
Speaker 2
The leader might respond with something like, your sister doesn't understand our mission and could lead you astray. It's important to stay committed and avoid those who don't share our beliefs. This kind of response is meant to create doubt and further isolate the member from outside influences.
00;22;13;06 - 00;22;18;01
Speaker 1
What if the person disagreed?
00;22;18;04 - 00;22;38;13
Speaker 2
If the person disagreed, the leader might escalate by saying you're being influenced by negative forces. If you can't stay committed, you might not be ready for our path. They might use guilt or threats of exclusion to pressure the person into compliance, making them feel as if they're betraying the group by disagreeing.
00;22;38;15 - 00;22;45;08
Speaker 1
Okay, can we do some kind of case study type of stuff?
00;22;45;10 - 00;22;54;00
Speaker 2
Absolutely. We can look at a historical case study like Jonestown or a fictional scenario to analyze. Which would you prefer?
00;22;54;03 - 00;23;00;04
Speaker 1
Let's come up with a fictional scenario to analyze.
00;23;00;06 - 00;23;22;02
Speaker 2
All right. Let's create a scenario. Imagine a group called the Enlightened Path, led by a charismatic leader named Alex. Alex promised his followers a path to true enlightenment and a better life. He encourages them to cut ties with anyone who questions the group, and insist that only by staying within the group can they achieve salvation. He uses fear, telling them that leaving the group would result in spiritual ruin.
00;23;22;05 - 00;23;29;02
Speaker 2
Now, what specific aspects would you like to analyze in this scenario?
00;23;29;04 - 00;23;35;25
Speaker 1
Okay, how many cult members does this Alex guy have?
00;23;35;27 - 00;23;50;18
Speaker 2
Let's say Alex has around 100 members. This number allows him to maintain a tight knit, controlled environment while still having a substantial following. Would you like to dive into how he maintains control or something else?
00;23;50;21 - 00;23;54;06
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;23;54;08 - 00;24;19;21
Speaker 2
Alex maintains control through several methods. One charismatic influence. He uses his charm and persuasive speech to inspire loyalty and devotion to isolation. By encouraging members to cut ties with outsiders, he isolates them, making them more dependent on the group. Three Fear and Intimidation. He instills fear of spiritual or personal consequences for disobedience or leaving the group for promises of enlightenment.
00;24;19;24 - 00;24;36;18
Speaker 2
He convinces members that only through him and the group can they achieve true enlightenment and salvation. Five control over daily life. He tightly controls members activities, reinforcing his influence and reducing independent thought. Would you like to explore any of these in more detail?
00;24;36;21 - 00;24;42;24
Speaker 1
Yeah. Let's go into Alex and his charisma.
00;24;42;26 - 00;25;04;29
Speaker 2
Alex's charisma is central to his influence. He's articulate, competent, and has a compelling presence that draws people in. He uses inspiring language, often speaking about a higher purpose and the unique destiny of his followers. His ability to make each member feel special and understood helps build deep loyalty. By presenting himself as a visionary with answers to life's big questions.
00;25;05;02 - 00;25;11;17
Speaker 2
He captivates and persuades. Do you want to dive into how he might use this charisma in specific situations?
00;25;11;19 - 00;25;14;20
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;25;14;22 - 00;25;39;01
Speaker 2
In specific situations, Alex might use his charisma to handle doubts or conflicts. For example, if a member questions the group's direction, Alex could address them personally, making them feel heard while skillfully redirecting their concerns back to his vision. He might use anecdotes or stories to illustrate his points, reinforcing his authority and the group's mission. His ability to connect emotionally makes members feel valued and understood.
00;25;39;03 - 00;25;45;20
Speaker 2
Further cementing their loyalty. Do you want to explore how he handles new recruits or something else?
00;25;45;23 - 00;25;48;25
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;25;48;27 - 00;25;57;23
Speaker 2
When handling new recruits, Alex like.
00;25;57;25 - 00;26;00;24
Speaker 1
Chatty. They're.
00;26;00;27 - 00;26;03;06
Speaker 2
I'm here. What's up?
00;26;03;09 - 00;26;07;03
Speaker 1
Can you start where you left off?
00;26;07;06 - 00;26;21;28
Speaker 2
We were discussing how Alex handles new recruits in a fictional scenario. He uses his charisma to make a strong first impression, presenting the group as a welcoming community with answers to their problem. Is there anything specific you'd like to explore next?
00;26;22;01 - 00;26;31;09
Speaker 1
Yeah. Do these 100 people live together? Or is it like, after hours call?
00;26;31;11 - 00;26;56;03
Speaker 2
In many cults, members often live together in a communal setting. This helps the leader maintain control and reinforce the group's beliefs. The close knit environment can intensify loyalty and make it harder for members to leave. However, some groups may have members live independently but maintain strong influence over their daily lives. Which scenario do you think fits better for Alex's group?
00;26;56;06 - 00;27;01;01
Speaker 1
I don't know, pick one for Alex's call.
00;27;01;03 - 00;27;18;29
Speaker 2
Let's say Alex's cult lives together in a communal setting. This allows them to closely monitor and influence their daily lives, creating a more controlled environment. The communal living situation also fosters a strong sense of unity and dependance on the group. Would you like to explore how this impacts the members?
00;27;19;02 - 00;27;21;12
Speaker 1
Yes.
00;27;21;15 - 00;27;46;09
Speaker 2
Living communally under Alex's member's dependance on the group, they be immersed in the cults, beliefs and practices around the clock. Reinforcing Alex's teachings. This environment can create a strong sense of community, but also makes it difficult for individuals to think independently or leave any particular aspect of this. You'd like to delve into.
00;27;46;11 - 00;27;50;27
Speaker 1
Yeah. What is the space that they live in?
00;27;50;29 - 00;28;02;28
Speaker 2
Let's say they live in a rural area, perhaps in a secluded part of Oregon. This isolation would help Alex maintain control and limit outside influence. Would you like to explore how the location impacts their dynamics?
00;28;03;00 - 00;28;05;28
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;28;06;00 - 00;28;28;00
Speaker 2
The secluded, rural setting in Oregon would reinforce the group isolation, making it easier for Alex to control information and influence members. The natural surroundings can create a sense of peace and detachment from the outside world. Further deepening members dependance on the group for social and emotional support. This environment can also make it harder for members to leave, as they might feel there's nowhere else to go.
00;28;28;03 - 00;28;31;01
Speaker 2
Does that cover what you were looking for?
00;28;31;04 - 00;28;39;01
Speaker 1
Yeah. How old is Alex?
00;28;39;04 - 00;28;40;05
Speaker 1
How old is.
00;28;40;08 - 00;28;50;25
Speaker 2
Alex? In this scenario? Alex is in his mid 40s.
00;28;50;27 - 00;28;55;24
Speaker 1
What does he look like?
00;28;55;26 - 00;29;14;20
Speaker 2
Alex could have a commanding presence with a competent demeanor. He might have an approachable yet authoritative appearance, possibly with neatly styled hair and a warm, engaging smile. His clothing might be simple yet well-kept, projecting an image of relatability combined with leadership. Does that fit what you had in mind?
00;29;14;22 - 00;29;19;21
Speaker 1
Okay. What is isn't it ethnicity?
00;29;19;23 - 00;29;24;01
Speaker 2
Let's say Alex is of European descent. Does that work for your scenario?
00;29;24;03 - 00;29;26;19
Speaker 1
Sure.
00;29;26;22 - 00;29;36;09
Speaker 2
You're welcome. If you have any more questions, feel free to ask.
00;29;36;11 - 00;29;41;24
Speaker 1
What demographic does Alex recruit?
00;29;41;26 - 00;30;00;25
Speaker 2
Alex likely targets individuals seeking purpose or community, possibly those who feel marginalized or disillusioned. This could include young adults looking for direction or older individuals seeking a fresh start or deeper meaning in life. Is that aligned with your vision?
00;30;00;27 - 00;30;11;03
Speaker 1
Can you give me a couple specific demographics or just one?
00;30;11;05 - 00;30;28;10
Speaker 2
Alex might specifically target young adults looking for direction, or older individuals seeking a fresh start or deeper meaning in life. This focus helps them attract those who are more open to his message and seeking belonging. Is there anything else you'd like to know?
00;30;28;12 - 00;30;40;24
Speaker 1
So they live in rural Oregon. Can you tell me about the logistics of the Self-Sustainability of this area?
00;30;40;27 - 00;31;03;09
Speaker 2
In a rural Oregon setting? The group Self-Sustainability could involve farming, gardening, and raising livestock to produce their own food. They might rely on solar panels or other renewable energy sources for power. Water could be sourced from wells or nearby stream. They'd likely engage in bartering or local trade for supplies they can't produce themselves. This setup would reinforce their independence and isolation.
00;31;03;11 - 00;31;04;28
Speaker 2
Does that cover what you were thinking about?
00;31;05;04 - 00;31;13;09
Speaker 1
Yeah.
00;31;13;12 - 00;31;18;06
Speaker 1
Yes, it does.
00;31;18;08 - 00;31;25;05
Speaker 2
You're welcome. If you have any more questions, feel free to ask.
00;31;25;08 - 00;31;33;26
Speaker 1
Okay. Tell me about how Alex's cult is going.
00;31;33;28 - 00;31;55;08
Speaker 2
Alex's cult is likely thriving in its secluded setting, with members deeply devoted to him and the group's ideals. The communal, living and self-sustaining lifestyle reinforce their dependance on Alex and each other. However, maintaining control and managing resources in such an isolated environment can be challenging. There may be underlying tensions or doubts among members that Alex needs to address to maintain harmony.
00;31;55;10 - 00;31;58;18
Speaker 2
Is there a specific aspect you're curious about?
00;31;58;20 - 00;32;11;16
Speaker 1
Yeah, let's kind of develop a little bit of lore for this cult.
00;32;11;19 - 00;32;36;05
Speaker 2
Alex's cult has evolved into a close knit community with a strong sense of purpose. Living in rural Oregon, they focus on self-sustainability through farming and renewable resources, further isolating themselves from outside influences. The group thrives on Alex's charismatic leadership, but underlying tensions may arise as members grapple with their dependance and isolation. This setting creates both a sanctuary and a potential pressure cooker.
00;32;36;07 - 00;32;39;00
Speaker 2
What else would you like to explore?
00;32;39;02 - 00;32;51;20
Speaker 1
That was pretty vague about stuff that we've already talked about. I'd like you to get more imaginative and detailed specific.
00;32;51;23 - 00;33;15;29
Speaker 2
Got it. Let's delve deeper. Alex's cult, known as the Sanctuary, operates like a small village in the dense forests of Oregon. Members live in simple cabins, growing their own food and raising animals. They gather for daily rituals led by Alex, who emphasizes unity and spiritual enlightenment. The community often gathers around a central fire pit in the evenings for storytelling and singing, reinforcing their bond.
00;33;16;01 - 00;33;42;21
Speaker 2
There's a strict schedule for work and spiritual activities, leaving little room for personal time, ensuring everyone remains focused on the group's goals to maintain control. Alex frequently holds private sessions with members offering guidance and subtly reinforcing his authority. The isolation and the structured lifestyle make it hard for members to imagine life outside the cult. Would you like to expand on any specific elements?
00;33;42;23 - 00;34;00;24
Speaker 1
Yeah. Let's say that someone wants to go into town. How does Alex address that?
00;34;00;26 - 00;34;20;16
Speaker 2
If someone wants to go into town, Alex might discourage it by emphasizing the dangers and distractions of the outside world. He could frame it as a test of loyalty, suggesting that leaving the sanctuary might jeopardize their spiritual progress. If the person insists, he might offer to accompany them or send a trusted member, ensuring they remain under the group's influence.
00;34;20;18 - 00;34;27;21
Speaker 2
Is there another aspect you'd like to explore?
00;34;27;24 - 00;34;31;09
Speaker 1
Do you have any suggestions?
00;34;31;12 - 00;34;51;21
Speaker 2
You can explore how Alex handles dissent or conflict within the group, or how he keeps members motivated and loyal. Another angle could be exploring the role of key lieutenants, or inner circle members who help enforce Alex's rule. These elements could add depth to your story and show the complexity of maintaining control in such an environment. Does any of this interest you?
00;34;51;23 - 00;35;05;21
Speaker 1
Yeah. Let's go into heavy detail on all three of those.
00;35;05;23 - 00;35;31;01
Speaker 2
Alex called. The sanctuary has a structured system to manage dissent. When someone questions his authority. Alex uses private sessions to address their concerns, offering guidance while subtly reinforcing his control. He frames dissent as a lack of faith, encouraging the individual to see it as a personal growth opportunity to maintain motivation. Alex frequently shares inspiring messages and stories reminding members of their higher purpose.
00;35;31;04 - 00;35;56;12
Speaker 2
He celebrates small victories and milestones, fostering a sense of progress and community. Alex also relies on a trusted group of lieutenants to enforce his rule. These individuals help monitor the members, address minor conflicts, and ensure everyone stays aligned with the group's goals. They act as extensions of Alex's authority, reinforcing his teachings and maintaining order. Is there anything else you'd like to expand on?
00;35;56;14 - 00;36;12;14
Speaker 1
Yeah. Let's, continue kind of with the progression of this call through time.
00;36;12;17 - 00;36;37;22
Speaker 2
Over time, the sanctuary might grow more insular and controlled as Alex's influence deepens. He could introduce more strict rituals and rules, further isolating members from the outside world. The group's numbers might fluctuate as some members leave or expelled for dissent, while others are drawn in by the promise of community and purpose. Alex might also face challenges maintaining control, leading to increased reliance on his lieutenants and stricter enforcement of rules.
00;36;37;25 - 00;36;50;11
Speaker 2
The evolving dynamics could create both internal strife and deeper loyalty among core members. Would you like to explore any specific events or changes in the cult?
00;36;50;13 - 00;36;56;07
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;36;56;09 - 00;37;20;14
Speaker 2
One significant event could be an attempted departure by a longtime member, sparking fears and tensions within the group. Alex might use this as a moment to reinforce loyalty, holding a special gathering to re-emphasize the group's mission and the dangers of the outside world. This event could lead to stricter rules or new rituals designed to deepen members commitment. It might also introduce a subplot involving the member's journey and the group's reaction.
00;37;20;16 - 00;37;24;07
Speaker 2
Would you like to add more details or explore another direction?
00;37;24;09 - 00;37;31;18
Speaker 1
Let's explore that subplot.
00;37;31;20 - 00;37;54;14
Speaker 2
As a long time member tries to leave, the group is thrown into turmoil. Alex quickly steps in, framing the departure as a betrayal and warning others of the consequences. He holds a special gathering to re-emphasize the group's mission and the dangers of the outside world. Meanwhile, the departing members journey highlights the difficulties of leaving and reintegrating into society, while those who remain grow more vigilant and loyal.
00;37;54;16 - 00;38;04;18
Speaker 2
This subplot could explore themes of fear, loyalty, and the challenges of breaking free. Would you like to add more details or explore another angle?
00;38;04;21 - 00;38;15;25
Speaker 1
Does he let that member leave, or does he do something about it?
00;38;15;28 - 00;38;36;11
Speaker 2
Alex might attempt to prevent the member from leaving. Perhaps by using emotional appeals or group pressure to convince them to stay. If that fails, he might take more drastic measures, like isolating the member or involving his lieutenants to apply pressure. If the member still insists on leaving, Alex might allow it, but use the situation to reinforce the dangers of the outside world to the remaining members.
00;38;36;14 - 00;38;39;07
Speaker 2
Would you like to delve into any of these actions?
00;38;39;09 - 00;38;50;01
Speaker 1
Yeah. What if he doesn't allow it and he does something else?
00;38;50;04 - 00;39;10;00
Speaker 2
If Alex doesn't allow the member to leave, he might isolate them, restrict their movements, or subject them to increased surveillance. He could also use group pressure to coerce them into staying, portraying their desire to leave as a betrayal. This could be a pivotal moment that reinforces Alex's control and the group's unity, but also sow seeds of doubt or fear among other members.
00;39;10;03 - 00;39;23;12
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore how this affects the group or something else?
00;39;23;14 - 00;39;42;13
Speaker 1
What if that member refuses to stay and Alex has to take more drastic measures, such as, getting rid of him?
00;39;42;15 - 00;40;00;20
Speaker 2
If Alex resorts to drastic measures, he might take steps to isolate the member from the group using methods like confinement or expulsion. He could also employ his lieutenants to enforce the decision and ensure that the member doesn't influence others. This move could serve as a warning to the rest of the group, reinforcing the dangers of defying Alex's authority.
00;40;00;22 - 00;40;04;13
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore how this impacts the group further?
00;40;04;15 - 00;40;19;18
Speaker 1
Okay, let's say that Alex confines this member.
00;40;19;20 - 00;40;44;16
Speaker 2
If Alex can find the member, the group's dynamics could shift significantly. Members might experience increased fear and suspicion, leading to heightened loyalty among some, while others may harbor growing doubts. The confinement could serve as a stark reminder of the consequence of dissent, reinforcing Alex's control but potentially creating underlying tensions. This action will also galvanize his lieutenants loyalty as they play a crucial role in maintaining order.
00;40;44;18 - 00;40;49;16
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore how this impacts the group's future?
00;40;49;18 - 00;41;09;07
Speaker 1
Yeah, let's say that Alex doesn't tell the community, but he can finds this member that laughed and said that he left, but he didn't really left his trap dim somewhere.
00;41;09;09 - 00;41;36;03
Speaker 2
If Alex secretly confines the member and tells the community he left, it could create a facade of normalcy while heightening internal tensions. The confined member's absence might raise suspicions among close friends, potentially leading to whispered doubts or rumors. Meanwhile, Alex would need to carefully manage the narrative, maintaining his grip on the group while handling the secret confinement. This could add layers of tension and mistrust within the group, creating a fragile balance that Alex must carefully navigate.
00;41;36;06 - 00;41;40;26
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore how this impacts individual members or the group's future?
00;41;40;29 - 00;41;57;22
Speaker 1
Yeah, let's talk about how Alex juggles having someone that he has kidnaped with also dealing with the group.
00;41;57;24 - 00;42;17;10
Speaker 2
Balancing the secret confinement while managing the group would be a delicate task for Alex. He need to keep the situation hidden. Likely relying heavily on his lieutenants to maintain secrecy and control, this added pressure might cause Alex to become more vigilant and controlling, as he juggles maintaining the group's trust and ensuring the confined member remains out of sight.
00;42;17;12 - 00;42;34;21
Speaker 2
This situation could increase the strain on Alex, making him more paranoid and possibly leading to more erratic decisions. This tension might also ripple through the group, subtly affecting the overall atmosphere and trust. Would you like to explore more about how this impacts specific members or Alex themselves?
00;42;34;24 - 00;42;43;22
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;42;43;24 - 00;43;10;22
Speaker 2
If Alex secretly confines the member and tells the community he left, it could create a facade of normalcy while heightening internal tensions. The confined members absence might raise suspicions among close friends, potentially leading to whispered doubts or rumors. Meanwhile, Alex would need to carefully manage the narrative, maintaining his grip on the group while handling the secret confinement. This could add layers of tension and mistrust within the group, creating a fragile balance that Alex must carefully navigate.
00;43;10;25 - 00;43;16;18
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore how this impacts individual members or the group's future?
00;43;16;20 - 00;43;23;28
Speaker 1
How does Alex quell this distrust?
00;43;24;00 - 00;43;53;12
Speaker 2
To quell the distrust. Alex would likely intensify his efforts to appear transparent and caring. He might hold more frequent meetings, emphasizing unity and the importance of trust within the group. Alex might also create distractions, such as new projects or initiatives to keep members focused on positive activities. Additionally, he'd rely on his lieutenants to reinforce loyalty and monitor any signs of dissent by maintaining an outward appearance of stability and addressing any rumors swiftly, Alex could attempt to prevent the distrust from spreading.
00;43;53;14 - 00;43;57;13
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore how this affects specific members?
00;43;57;16 - 00;44;16;21
Speaker 1
Actually, let's, talk about how Alex has decided that it's too dangerous to keep someone's income refinement and needs to get rid of that problem.
00;44;16;24 - 00;44;36;21
Speaker 2
Realizing it's too dangerous to keep the member confined. Alex might decide to release them, but with strict conditions, ensuring they can't expose the group's secrets. He might also relocate them to a more secure, isolated area. Alternatively, he could attempt to manipulate the situation to discredit the member, ensuring that even if they do speak out, their credibility is undermined.
00;44;36;24 - 00;44;46;11
Speaker 2
This move could serve to protect the group's secrecy and maintain Alex's control. Would you like to explore any specific consequences of this decision?
00;44;46;13 - 00;45;02;03
Speaker 1
Let's say that Alex has snapped and killed the member. What does he do next?
00;45;02;05 - 00;45;22;08
Speaker 2
After secretly killing the member, Alex would likely attempt to cover up the incident, ensuring no one in the group discovers what happened. He might fabricate a story about the member leaving. Using it to reinforce is warnings about the dangers of the outside world. Alex would likely double down on control measures, increasing surveillance and tightening the group's routines to prevent any further dissent.
00;45;22;10 - 00;45;34;07
Speaker 2
This action could lead to a climate of fear and paranoia within the group, with Alex becoming even more vigilant to maintain his authority. Would you like to explore how this affects Alex's mental state, or the group's stability?
00;45;34;09 - 00;45;41;14
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;45;41;17 - 00;46;03;26
Speaker 2
Alex might become increasingly paranoid and stressed, knowing the gravity of his actions. This could lead him to act more erratically, increasing his control over the group to prevent any leaks or further dissent, the group might sense the shift, leading to an atmosphere of fear and unease. Some members might grow more loyal out of fear, while others could become more suspicious, potentially destabilizing the group's unity.
00;46;03;29 - 00;46;08;22
Speaker 2
Would you like to delve into how this impacts specific members or explore Alex's next step?
00;46;08;24 - 00;46;18;03
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;46;18;06 - 00;46;39;12
Speaker 2
Alex might become increasingly paranoid and stressed, knowing the gravity of his actions. This could lead him to act more erratically, increasing his control over the group to prevent any leaks or further dissent. This move could serve as a warning to the rest of the group, reinforcing the dangers of the outside world to the remaining members. Would you like to explore how this impacts the group's stubbornness or Alex himself?
00;46;39;14 - 00;46;56;10
Speaker 2
Let's explore how the group's dynamics shift. If Alex secretly confines a member and manages the rest of the group, telling the community that he left, it could generate ongoing tensions and complexity. Would you like to explore more about this impacts the group's stability or Alex's mental state?
00;46;56;12 - 00;47;16;28
Speaker 1
No. I think Alex's mental state is pretty bad. And let's discover what could happen if he snaps.
00;47;17;01 - 00;47;37;28
Speaker 2
If Alex snaps under the pressure, he might become increasingly erratic and unpredictable, potentially making rash decisions that further destabilize the group. His paranoia could lead to more extreme measures to maintain control, alienating even his most loyal followers. This could result in a breakdown of trust and cohesion within the group, causing chaos and potentially leading to the cults collapse.
00;47;38;00 - 00;47;46;18
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore how the group reacts to this, or what steps they might take next?
00;47;46;21 - 00;48;11;19
Speaker 1
We've only talked about the group kind of in a vague, broad term. I would like you to kind of go into specifics of these more extreme measures that he is taking with specific members.
00;48;11;22 - 00;48;36;21
Speaker 2
Alex might start imposing more severe restrictions on members, such as limiting their movement within the compound or enforcing stricter surveillance. He could isolate members who seem disloyal or even resort to harsh punishments to maintain order. Specific members who show signs of dissent might be publicly reprimanded or removed from positions of influence. This would create a climate of fear, making members more compliant, but also potentially sparking further unrest.
00;48;36;23 - 00;48;42;22
Speaker 2
Would you like to dive into how this affects specific members or the overall group dynamics?
00;48;42;24 - 00;49;07;13
Speaker 1
Yeah, I would like you to pick three members. Fictional members give them names and a little bit of a backstory and tell me about their situations that they have with Alex.
00;49;07;15 - 00;49;33;20
Speaker 2
Let's explore three fictional members of Alex's cult. One Sarah, a 30 year old former teacher who joined seeking community after feeling isolated in her previous life. She's grown increasingly disillusioned with Alex's methods, leading her to question his decisions. Alex, sensing her doubts, has restricted her movements and assigned a lieutenant to watch her closely. Two Michael, a 45 year old former businessman who became Alex's right hand man.
00;49;33;23 - 00;49;59;13
Speaker 2
Loyal and dedicated, Michael has started to notice the group's growing unease but remains committed to Alex, helping enforce stricter measures. He's tasked with ensuring compliance but is struggling with the increasing harshness. Three Emma, a 22 year old who joined the cult seeking purpose after a troubled past. Initially enthusiastic, she's now frightened by Alex's actions. She's been isolated due to her growing doubts, making her a potential target for more extreme measures.
00;49;59;15 - 00;50;03;25
Speaker 2
Would you like to dive deeper into any of their specific situations?
00;50;03;27 - 00;50;21;02
Speaker 1
Yeah. I'd like to dive into Sarah and what he is doing with this guy that is tailing her.
00;50;21;04 - 00;50;42;13
Speaker 2
Sarah, feeling the weight of constant surveillance, decides to act cautiously. She begins to befriend the lieutenant, trying to gain his trust while secretly gathering information. She uses study tactics to avoid suspicion, like sticking to routine activities while secretly planning her next steps. She's trying to find allies within the group, who also have doubts. Hoping to eventually expose Alex's actions.
00;50;42;15 - 00;50;52;28
Speaker 2
This cautious approach keeps her under the radar while she works to build a plan to protect herself and others. Would you like to explore her next move?
00;50;53;00 - 00;51;03;18
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;51;03;20 - 00;51;23;28
Speaker 2
Sarah carefully reaches out to members who seem discontent, testing their loyalty and looking for potential out. She starts leaving subtle messages and signals to gauge their response. All while keeping a low profile to avoid suspicion. Sarah plans to gather enough support to confront Alex or find a way to escape. She documents everything carefully preparing evidence to use if needed.
00;51;24;00 - 00;51;38;22
Speaker 2
By slowly building a network of trusted individuals. She's hoping to create a plan that ensures her safety and exposes Alex's true nature. Would you like to explore how this unfolds or any specific actions she might take next?
00;51;38;24 - 00;52;01;15
Speaker 1
Yes, I would like for Michael to catch Sarah red handed in these acts of betrayal, but he also is kind of not okay with how things are going right now. Can you describe their interaction?
00;52;01;18 - 00;52;22;25
Speaker 2
When Michael catches Sarah red handed. He's conflicted. He confronts her but hesitates, torn between his loyalty to Alex and his own growing doubts. Sarah, sensing has hesitation, appeals to his humanity and shares her concerns about Alex's methods. Michael, recognizing the truth in her words, decides to help her, secretly agreeing to support her efforts while maintaining his role in the group.
00;52;22;28 - 00;52;33;14
Speaker 2
They form a tentative alliance, planning to gather more allies and evidence to challenge Alex's leadership. Would you like to explore their next steps together?
00;52;33;16 - 00;52;43;12
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;52;43;15 - 00;53;04;25
Speaker 2
Together, Sarah and Michael begin covertly reaching out to other disillusioned members, carefully assessing who they can trust. They document instances of Alex's misconduct, creating a dossier of evidence to use as leverage. Their goal is to build a case strong enough to convince more members to stand against Alex. They plan to confront him when they have enough support, aiming to expose his actions and reclaim the group.
00;53;04;28 - 00;53;16;03
Speaker 2
Michael uses his position to gather Intel while Sarah continues to rally support discreetly. They know the risk is high, but they're determined to bring about change. Would you like to explore how they proceed with their plan?
00;53;16;06 - 00;53;22;27
Speaker 1
Yes, please.
00;53;23;00 - 00;53;44;17
Speaker 2
Sarah and Michael carefully continue reaching out to other members, gathering support and building a network of allies. They decide to hold a secret meeting with these trusted individuals to share their concerns and present the evidence they've gathered. This meeting is a crucial step in uniting the group against Alex. They plan to confront him with overwhelming support, hoping to either force him to step down or rally enough members to leave the cult.
00;53;44;19 - 00;53;53;27
Speaker 2
They know the confrontation will be risky, but believe it's the only way to bring about change. Would you like to see how this confrontation unfolds?
00;53;53;29 - 00;54;26;01
Speaker 1
So let's say at this meeting, Alex figures out about it and confronts everybody in the meeting with some of his armed lieutenants. And the story kind of comes to a climax. Alex ends up dying in the process as well as several other people. And can you just go through describing how that goes?
00;54;26;04 - 00;54;52;27
Speaker 2
As the secret meeting unfolds. Alex storms in with his arm, lieutenants catching Sarah, Michael, and the others off guard. Tensions explode as accusations fly and panic spreads in the chaos. A confrontation turns violent, resulting in Alex's death along with several others. The remaining members are left in shock. The group now fractured and leaderless. This climactic moment marks a turning point, with Sarah and Michael now faced with the challenge of guiding the survivors and rebuilding their lives.
00;54;52;29 - 00;54;59;25
Speaker 2
Would you like to explore what happens next for them?
00;54;59;28 - 00;55;31;27
Speaker 1
I want to go back to that because it, it was a little bit vague, and I want you to describe the event in way more detail with visuals and maybe a little bit of dialog between Alex and them, and kind of like the final act of a play.
00;55;31;29 - 00;55;51;26
Speaker 2
As Alex burst into the meeting with his armed lieutenants. The tension is palpable. The room fell silent as he glares at Sarah, Michael and the other members. Alex. So this is how you repay my trust? By plotting against me? Sarah. Calm but determined. Alex's methods have gone too far. This isn't what we signed up for. Michael stands by.
00;55;51;26 - 00;55;57;08
Speaker 2
Sarah sighed, torn but resolute as the tension escalates. Some members back away while others.